Hard questions

The objections, answered

66 hard questions from 19 essays, each with the essay’s own answer and a link to read it in context.

Isn’t this just socialism, or UBI, or a fantasy?

The most common first reaction is that this is an old idea with a new name. These answers explain what’s different.

  1. Isn’t this just degrowth?

    No. Degrowth says shrink the economy. I’m saying shrink the drawdown and grow everything else: energy, food, goods, recycling, science.

    To be fair, Daly, the founder of steady-state economics, whose ideas helped inspire degrowth, went further than I do. In that 1990 paper, he called “sustainable growth” a “bad oxymoron,” because he saw the economy as a subsystem of a finite planet. He separated growth, defined as getting physically bigger, from development, defined as getting better.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    On this planet’s stocks, I agree with him. There’s no question we have finite resources. Where I’d push back is on the boundary. The sun’s flow is enormous, materials can loop, and there are vast amounts of ore in space that nobody lives on top of.

    Abundant flows, conserved stocks and an outward frontier don’t make a smaller economy. They make a differently shaped one.

    In Part 9: The Earth should be a garden, not a mine

  2. Isn’t this just socialism with extra steps?

    It’s close to libertarian socialism, as I said. But it isn’t what most people picture when they hear “socialism.” Nobody’s labor gets planned, nobody’s business gets nationalized, and markets stay open for everything above the floor.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    What changes is that the machines that make the essentials belong to the places they serve, instead of to whoever bought them first, and calling on machine labor is everyone’s right.

    In Part 10: A floor for everyone, a frontier for anyone

  3. It’s a kids’ game. Why take its economics seriously?

    Because kids did. Millions of us grew up inside this world, and it shaped what we think is normal: free healthcare, partners who are also coworkers, help you can summon. The people who’ll live in the next economy have already played the tutorial.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    And the longtime Game Freak director Junichi Masuda said in a 2012 interview that the Pokémon world has no global warming or water shortages because “the people in it really want to work together with each other.” That’s a design choice, and it’s one we could make too.

    In Part 13: Pokémon already showed us how machine labor should work

  4. Isn’t this just the gig economy?

    No. It’s the opposite.

    The gig economy is what Handy’s portfolio life turned into without a floor. In a 2021 Pew Research survey, 16% of Americans said they had ever earned money through an online gig platform.

    Read the full answer (4 more paragraphs)

    Among current or recent gig workers, roughly six in ten said that money was essential (23%) or important (35%) for meeting their basic needs.

    That’s a portfolio built on fear. You juggle gigs because you have to, and every one of them can vanish.

    A skill tree flips each part. The floor comes first. Nobody is paid to play, so no platform sits between you and your craft taking a cut.

    And your skills, ranks and quest log belong to you, not to an app.

    In Part 14: You won’t have a career. You’ll have a skill tree.

  5. Isn’t this just capitalism with medals?

    No. In capitalism, the loser can lose their home, and the winner can buy up the field. In a league, the loser drops a division, and the winner gets a harder schedule. The floor is outside the game, the machines that make it belong to the town’s trust, and there’s nothing to buy.

    In Part 15: The Olympics, but for everything

  6. Isn’t this just spiritual fluff?

    Fair question. I’m not asking anyone to believe anything supernatural.

    Everything in this piece rests on things you can check: Maslow’s own later writing, decades of research on awe and curiosity, and astronaut accounts that researchers describe as spiritual experiences outside any religion.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    You can read all of it as psychology and lose nothing. “Soul alignment” is my phrase for the experience, not a doctrine. If you prefer “a really good walk,” that works too.

    In Part 16: Above self-actualization is the universe

  7. Isn’t this central planning?

    Planning failed because one center tried to know everything. This has no center: each town holds its own data, prices still carry local knowledge, and any town can leave with its node, once it settles what it owes.

    In Part 17: Keep money, add a second ledger

  8. Why not just give people cash?

    Sometimes you should. In a demand collapse, cash is exactly right, and I’d keep it ready. But cash can’t build a water main, tell you one is leaking, or move spare grain from a valley to a desert town.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    A check only works if the things it buys exist and can reach you. The second ledger is how we make sure they do.

    In Part 17: Keep money, add a second ledger

  9. Isn’t the cash floor just UBI?

    Close. Everyone gets the same payment, but every dollar you earn is taxed, so for most working adults it nets out, and they’re net taxpayers.

    That’s a negative income tax: generous at the bottom, gone by the middle. And it’s a floor for the transition, not the destination. The destination is the things, not the check (Part 6).

    In Part 18: Every spending bill should show up on your paycheck

  10. Isn’t this just gig work with a nicer name?

    Without the five rules, yes. That’s what’s happening right now. The difference is ownership.

    A gig worker sells footage once. A cooperative member keeps a share of everything it trains.

    In Part 20: Get paid to train the robot that takes your job

  11. Isn’t this all a fantasy?

    Look at the world we’re actually building. It’s a world where nothing is defensible, because everything can be remixed and regenerated at a moment’s notice.

    Today that’s true of digital things. Soon it will be true of physical things too.

    Read the full answer (4 more paragraphs)

    The current system doesn’t make sense for that world. We need to build for where the puck is going, not where it is now: a world where information flows freely, and its value lies in distributing it and in the creativity that grows from it.

    I also think the economic system we build next will feel a lot more like a video game than today’s does. That won’t seem weird to anyone who grew up playing them, and honestly, we’re already halfway there.

    The internet already runs on game mechanics: likes, follower counts, star ratings, and two-way scoring, where drivers rate riders and riders rate drivers. Parties, guilds, and quests aren’t a metaphor I picked at random.

    Games have been prototyping new ways to organize people, reward contribution, and build reputation for decades. Software and video games give us real, tested paths for adjusting to this economic reality.

    In Part 22: Five takes the AI industry needs to ingest

  12. Why would anyone want this?

    Because it’s what most people already want.

    Most people just want a good time with their friends and their immediate surroundings: a good life in their own neighborhood, and the freedom to travel when they get bored or need a refresh.

    Read the full answer (6 more paragraphs)

    We don’t want to be constantly competing with everyone on the planet to be the best, just to survive.

    We want to survive first. Then choose the venues where we want to compete, or contribute.

    And mostly, that means making our local environments better. So let’s make every local environment resilient first, and self-sufficient by region in time, so we’re not just surviving, but thriving.

    Machine labor on demand can do that. So can understanding, documenting, and simulating every physical thing we depend on.

    And once we have that knowledge, distributing it and making it accessible lets everyone understand it, change it, and steer it toward something better.

    So we can pursue our curiosity. Compete in the venues we choose. And care for each other. Curiosity, competition, and care: that’s what the floor is for (Part 8).

    In Part 22: Five takes the AI industry needs to ingest

  13. Why are you building this at all?

    Marianna Ganapini put it bluntly: she doesn’t understand why US labs and VC firms are so obsessed with AGI. Is it China? Is it playing God? Is it just because they can?

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    Luiza Jarovsky went further, calling AI a non-essential technology, and arguing that AI companies are pushing society to accept an unacceptable level of risk for it.

    You don’t have to agree with either of them to see the problem. If you never explain what a technology is for, people will only see what it costs. Risk without a reason is just risk.

    A whole sectionIn Start here: The AI industry has never told you what’s in it for you

  14. Aren’t guilds just cartels?

    Medieval guilds also existed to restrict entry from newcomers and fix prices.

    I think about this in the context of the Writers Guild of America today. In order to join, you already have to have been paid to write for a studio that has signed on with the guild.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    This is a complete joke, and a great way to enforce high wages for an elite few at the expense of the many hundreds of thousands more who study the craft and want a chance to do it.

    A whole sectionIn Part 4: Quests should replace corporations

  15. “Isn’t that libertarian socialism?”

    That’s the obvious question, and my honest answer is: yeah, it pretty much is! Libertarian socialism, the anti-authoritarian, decentralized branch of the socialist tree, is the closest modern equivalent. Credit goes to the people who argued it first.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    Peter Kropotkin. In The Conquest of Bread (1892), Kropotkin argued that “Well-being for all is not a dream,” and proposed a rule that sounds a lot like the floor in Part 6: “no stint or limit to what the community possesses in abundance, but equal sharing and dividing of those commodities which are scarce or apt to run short.”

    In Mutual Aid (1902), he argued that cooperation is as much a factor in evolution as competition.

    A whole sectionIn Part 10: A floor for everyone, a frontier for anyone

Who pays for it, and why would owners let go?

Building the machines costs real money, and today’s owners profit from things staying scarce. These answers cover what builders earn, why they hand finished plants over to the towns they serve, and how taxes pay for the rest.

  1. Why would anyone who builds this infrastructure give it away?

    There are many reasons. They could agree to it up front, as a condition of public financing, or everyone could agree this is the world we want, and decide to do it.

    Read the full answer (3 more paragraphs)

    For example, some might do it for legacy.

    Instead of today’s billionaires gifting their wealth in shares and cash payments after they die, they could gift the infrastructure. In the long run, it’ll do us a lot more good.

    Others will agree to it up front as a condition of public money and permits, the same way utilities accept regulation today. And as parties take on net new build-outs as quests, more often the builders will be the community itself.

    In Part 5: Every town can own its own power plant and chip fab

  2. Would incumbents allow this?

    Probably not without pressure.

    Corporations that profit from scarcity have little reason to give it up, so this likely arrives through policy, competition from more efficient parties and guilds, and net new key infrastructure purpose-built with community ownership from the jump.

    In Part 5: Every town can own its own power plant and chip fab

  3. Why would billionaires ever give anything back?

    Some will, for legacy, the way Carnegie did. The rest should agree to it up front, as a condition of building. Written into the contract before the first shovel goes in, a gift-back is just a deal.

    In Part 10: A floor for everyone, a frontier for anyone

  4. Why would America give its technology away?

    Because it already did, with GPS, and won. Selling first gets the builders paid. Opening later makes the American stack the one the world builds on.

    In Part 10: A floor for everyone, a frontier for anyone

  5. Won’t this just pay the people who are already famous?

    That’s the real risk. Today’s systems mostly serve big catalogs: remember, only 7,626 rights holders can use Content ID.

    Three things push the other way. Provenance on by default, for everyone, not just approved partners. Open admission to guilds, so nobody is locked out of the chain.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    And the floor, so nobody depends on royalties to eat. In the world we want, getting remixed is a bonus, not your rent.

    In Part 11: Remix will kill the copy, not the creator

  6. Isn’t a flat tax a tax cut for the rich?

    It can be, which is why this isn’t a flat tax in the usual sense. Capital income pays more than wages. Gains get taxed when they’re sold or passed on at death, at the capital rate, with no discount.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    And the cash floor does the work that brackets used to do, out in the open, where it can be counted. If the floor is sized too small, then yes, this shifts the burden down. That’s why the floor gets sized first.

    In Part 18: Every spending bill should show up on your paycheck

  7. Won’t Congress just suspend the formula?

    Maybe. I don’t think any law can fully bind a future Congress, and the Swiss put theirs in the constitution, which is a much higher bar here. The three-fifths lock helps.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    But the real lock is visibility. Suspending the formula means voting to hide the price of what you’re spending. That’s a vote people would see on their next paycheck.

    In Part 18: Every spending bill should show up on your paycheck

  8. Why pay down debt during an AI transition?

    Because interest buys nothing, and it’s already bigger than defense. Fiscal 2026 closed with net interest of about $1.1 trillion, more than the government spent on defense or Medicare. And if markets start to expect transformative AI, economists Trevor Chow, Basil Halperin and J. Zachary Mazlish show that long-term real interest rates should rise.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    That makes carrying debt more expensive at exactly the wrong time. Paying it down while the transition is still gradual buys room for when it isn’t. And if it stops being gradual, the surcharge pauses on its own.

    In Part 18: Every spending bill should show up on your paycheck

  9. Why would robotics companies agree to share?

    Some won’t, and they’ll buy elsewhere. But the most useful data comes from skilled people practicing well, coached and consenting, in places built for it.

    That’s what a Foundry makes. Organized sellers of something scarce get better terms.

    In Part 20: Get paid to train the robot that takes your job

  10. Who’s going to pay for all of this?

    First, it’s worth remembering what money is: make-believe, a way to package belief as value. (I dig into that in Remix Will Kill the Copy, Not the Creator.)

    And right now, big corporations and investors are pouring their belief into AI. They’re funneling enormous amounts of money into models, chips, data centers, and robots.

    Read the full answer (5 more paragraphs)

    So my answer is: let them pay for it.

    From where they sit, it’s all upside. Either they own the machines and print money as machine labor replaces human labor, or they own the only form of labor that’s left, even as its price falls toward zero.

    Either way, they believe they win, which is why they’re investing.

    In the future, what machine labor on demand can produce will be defined by its inputs: energy, materials, and the physical parts it runs on. Whoever builds that capacity today is building the foundation everyone stands on tomorrow.

    So let them invest in it and build it today, so that we can all benefit from it tomorrow. They get their return. Then comes the gift-back.

    In Part 22: Five takes the AI industry needs to ingest

  11. Who keeps the rewards?

    Now the uncomfortable part. The Pokémon aren’t paid. They earn experience.

    Every item reward, from Heal Balls up to Big Nuggets, goes to the trainer. Gita Jackson put it bluntly at Kotaku the week the game came out: “They aren’t paid at all!”

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    If Pokémon are people, she’s right, and I’ll come back to that. But first, notice the question the job board raises, because machine labor raises the same one:

    A whole sectionIn Part 13: Pokémon already showed us how machine labor should work

Who controls the machines, and is it safe?

Spreading machines across thousands of towns raises fair questions about safety, privacy and who is in charge.

  1. Won’t my companion just be a company’s spy?

    If you rent it, it might be. That’s the whole reason to own it.

    An owned companion runs locally by default, keeps its memory on your device, calls the cloud only when you say so, and lets you take your memory with you if you switch. A robot companion lets remote operators in only when you invite them, the way you’d let a plumber in.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    And the law has to catch up. Altman himself said we should have “the same concept of privacy for your conversations with AI that we do with a therapist.”

    I agree, and I’d go further: the strongest version of that privilege is a companion that never sent the conversation anywhere to begin with.

    In Part 12: Your first party member should be an AI you own

  2. What happens when it’s smarter than me?

    In some ways, it already is. C-3PO was, in his own words from the script, “fluent in six million forms of communication.” Han wasn’t.

    But smarter doesn’t make it the boss. We all have friends who are smarter than us at something.

    Read the full answer (3 more paragraphs)

    We don’t hand them our lives. We ask their advice.

    A good companion should make you smarter, too. That was Engelbart’s whole point: augment the person.

    In Part 4, I pictured machine guild members teaching beginners “with all their infinite patience and infinite time.” Your companion can be that teacher.

    In Part 12: Your first party member should be an AI you own

  3. Why keep humans in charge if the machine is better at the odds?

    This is the hardest one, so let me be honest about the evidence.

    In 2024, researchers at MIT published a meta-analysis of 106 experiments on humans working with AI. On average, human-AI teams did worse than the best of humans or AI alone.

    Read the full answer (6 more paragraphs)

    The losses showed up in decision tasks, especially when the AI was already better than the human. The gains showed up in creative tasks, and when the human was better than the AI.

    So for a pure calculation, where there’s one right answer and the machine is better at finding it, let the machine calculate. Don’t second-guess the autopilot’s math.

    But most of the choices that matter in a life aren’t calculations. Which quest to go on. What risk is worth it. Who to bring along.

    Those are questions about what you value, and there’s no odds table for that.

    The odds are an input. The will is the decision.

    That’s the world we want: one that’s maximally free and maximally safe, where you get the best information in the galaxy and still get to choose.

    In Part 12: Your first party member should be an AI you own

  4. Isn’t comparing AI to Pokémon dangerous anthropomorphism?

    It can be. Pokémon are written as living creatures with feelings.

    Today’s AI systems aren’t proven to have either, and people already over-trust chatbots that sound warm. A loyal-pet analogy could make that worse.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    But the analogy runs on structure, not feelings. The questions Pokémon raises are about ownership, access, and refusal: who keeps the rewards, who gets healed for free, who gets to say no.

    Those matter whether or not machines feel anything. And if some of them turn out to, we’ll be glad we asked early.

    In Part 13: Pokémon already showed us how machine labor should work

  5. Pokémon are basically enslaved. Is that really your model?

    No. Poké Jobs is the warning, not the blueprint. If the workers were people, a world where they work unpaid and the boss keeps the Big Nuggets would be indefensible.

    Read the full answer (3 more paragraphs)

    What I’m taking is the rest of the picture: labor on demand, specialists, a free floor, partnership over ownership, and the right to refuse. The series keeps reaching for that too.

    Rangers who never own a Pokémon. Ryme City, the setting of the 2019 film Detective Pikachu, founded as a utopia where humans and Pokémon live and work side by side, and trainers and Poké Balls are banned.

    Ash’s Squirtle, who chose to leave and rejoin its old crew as a firefighter. The franchise has argued with itself about this for decades, and partnership by choice keeps winning.

    In Part 13: Pokémon already showed us how machine labor should work

  6. Doesn’t a “video game economy” just mean scoring everyone, all the time?

    It could, and that version is a nightmare. But we already score each other on every app. What matters is what’s at stake.

    In the world I’m describing, what you do with your time and what you use as your essential goods and services aren’t scored. In fact, what you need to survive isn’t scored at all: the Pokémon Center heals you whether you have one badge or eight.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    Reputation decides which quests you lead, and who you work with, not whether you eat. And because parties disband and guilds are open, you can always walk away and start over doing something else. There’s always a new beginning to be had.

    In Part 13: Pokémon already showed us how machine labor should work

  7. Isn’t measuring everything surveillance?

    It would be, if it measured people. It measures meters, warehouses and fabs.

    Household data stays home, and there’s no central switch. The acid rain program watched every smokestack without watching anyone.

    In Part 17: Keep money, add a second ledger

  8. Isn’t spreading out the machines just proliferation with better branding?

    For the most dangerous capabilities, yes, which is why the capability dial exists. But most of what this series puts in towns is robots for farms, clinics and power plants, plus assistants on your laptop. Those spread power, not doom.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    The frontier can be declared and inspected. The everyday fleet should be owned.

    In Part 24: Doom or foom, the answer is the same: own the machines

  9. If the doomers are right, isn’t this rearranging deck chairs?

    If they’re right and the brake never comes, maybe. But if they’re right, the brake has to be agreed to, enforced for years, and eventually lifted. Every one of those steps goes better when no small group gets to keep the future for itself.

    In Part 24: Doom or foom, the answer is the same: own the machines

  10. Won’t slower, shared ownership lose the race?

    To whom, and for what? AI 2027’s own happy ending shows what winning looks like: a committee of ten to twenty people.

    I’d rather win the way America won with GPS, as I described in Part 10: build it, then make it everyone’s.

    In Part 24: Doom or foom, the answer is the same: own the machines

  11. Who controls it?

    Ben Dickson worries that power is concentrating in the handful of labs and tech companies that can afford the GPU clusters, data centers, and power plants. He wants AI that can learn without consuming so much energy, so that more people can build it.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    Justin Bonanno makes the same point from the user’s side: everyone should learn to run a language model on their own machine. Ownership is agency.

    And even inside the industry, nobody agrees on who controls the pace. Nathan Lambert argued that slowing down the frontier sounds good in principle but is dead on arrival in practice. Who would decide which benchmarks get to improve?

    A whole sectionIn Start here: The AI industry has never told you what’s in it for you

  12. Who owns the machines?

    So, if people lose wages, they need some other claim on what machines produce.

    On Anarres, the moneyless moon of The Dispossessed, nobody owns anything: there are farms, factories, and distribution centers that produce essential goods, and they belong to no one and everyone.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    People simply use what they need.

    A whole sectionIn Part 5: Every town can own its own power plant and chip fab

  13. Why not the government?

    You might ask: why not just let the government own it all?

    Because we’ve seen how that goes.

    Centralized state ownership, the way communist economies tried it, tends to reward loyalty over results and leaves no one with a real stake in keeping things running.

    A whole sectionIn Part 5: Every town can own its own power plant and chip fab

  14. Who runs the machines?

    Owning the machines and running them are two different jobs. Who runs them depends on the job.

    Ownership follows the nature of the thing.

    Your town’s trust holds what’s tied to the place: the power, the water, the local machines that make the essentials, and the land trusts for housing. Under its charter, it stays answerable for one thing above all: delivering “the floor” (the essential goods and services) to everyone who lives there.

    A whole sectionIn Part 5: Every town can own its own power plant and chip fab

Will people still work, and will it feel fair?

If nobody has to work to survive, what happens to effort, mastery and the jobs nobody wants?

  1. If nobody has to work, won’t people stop doing anything?

    Some will rest for a while. Most won’t stay there. People want to build, compete, teach and make things.

    Just look at Sweden’s watches, or any video game. The golden rule doesn’t ask people to work. It guarantees they get to.

    In Part 10: A floor for everyone, a frontier for anyone

  2. Won’t everyone become a dabbler?

    Some people will dabble, and that’s fine. “Dilettante” comes from the Italian for “to delight,” and it originally meant a devoted amateur, with no insult attached. A town full of people who love a dozen things is not a problem to solve.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    But plenty of people will go deep, because depth is its own reward and the ladder is right there. Look at football: over a million people in England play for fun, and the climb never runs short of people who want it.

    In Part 14: You won’t have a career. You’ll have a skill tree.

  3. Who does the boring work?

    Machines, unless someone wants it. That’s the golden rule.

    Some people genuinely like work others find boring, and they get first pick.

    In Part 14: You won’t have a career. You’ll have a skill tree.

  4. What if I just want to do one thing my whole life?

    Then do it. Nothing here forces you to wander. The point isn’t that everyone should collect skills.

    The point is that nobody should be trapped in one.

    In Part 14: You won’t have a career. You’ll have a skill tree.

  5. Doesn’t the draft break up crews that love working together?

    In the competitive leagues, yes. That’s the point: the alternative is a few famous crews hoarding talent forever. But nobody has to enter a drafted league, and your crew can keep working together in friendlies and on its own quests.

    In Part 15: The Olympics, but for everything

  6. Won’t the home tier become second-class?

    Only if we let status flow one way. Most footballers already play in the lower tiers, and they don’t feel like failures. Give local leagues their own tables, champions and festivals, and they’ll be a culture, not a consolation prize.

    In Part 15: The Olympics, but for everything

  7. Who referees?

    Independent judges, appointed in public and scoring anonymously, like TidyTowns. Fixed rules for each season. And appeals to a body outside the league, because Harrison should never have had to fight his referees.

    In Part 15: The Olympics, but for everything

  8. Won’t people just watch TV forever?

    Some will, for a while. That’s allowed. I’ve done it.

    But let’s look at the data. In the 2025 American Time Use Survey, watching TV took up 2.6 hours a day, about half of all leisure time.

    Read the full answer (7 more paragraphs)

    That’s a lot. It’s also what people do at the end of a tiring day, inside a system that ties survival to a job.

    The more interesting finding is older. In 1989, the psychologists Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi and Judith LeFevre tracked workers through their week and found that people reported most of their flow experiences, those absorbed, challenging, time-disappears moments, at work, not at leisure, even though they reported feeling less motivated at work.

    People don’t crave idleness. They crave challenge they chose.

    That lines up with self-determination theory, the framework Richard Ryan and Edward Deci laid out in American Psychologist in 2000: people thrive when they feel competent, autonomous, and connected to others.

    That’s a pretty good description of a guild and a party.

    Guilds offer competence. The golden rule offers autonomy. Quests offer connection.

    Keynes worried we’d have nothing to do. I think the problem was never free time. It was the lack of good things to do with it.

    In Part 16: Above self-actualization is the universe

  9. Can’t AI be curious too?

    In a narrow sense, yes. Researchers have built curiosity-driven AI agents that reward themselves for exploring what they can’t yet predict.

    But that isn’t the curiosity I mean. Machines can help us search. They can’t do the wondering for us, any more than they can enjoy a meal for us.

    Read the full answer (3 more paragraphs)

    The experience of a question opening up inside you is yours. So is the urge to test yourself against others. So is the decision to care about someone.

    When I say these are the three things AI can’t automate, I don’t mean machines can’t imitate them. I mean that outsourcing them would defeat the point.

    Which is the golden rule, one more time. Machines can carry the load. The wanting is ours.

    In Part 16: Above self-actualization is the universe

  10. What happens when everything graduates?

    Then the bridge did its job.

    The dividends keep flowing from the machines, and the Foundries become what the original pictured at its best: places like Alpha School, which says kids can cover their academics in two hours a day, except for everyone, for life, and for the joy of it. That’s what the floor is for: curiosity, competition, and care (Part 8).

    In Part 20: Get paid to train the robot that takes your job

  11. What about the people who don’t want any of this?

    Let me be direct: not everyone will find this compelling. Some people don’t want to learn. Some people want to be told what to do (even if they won’t admit it). Some people DON’T want to be told what to do, and find this idea repulsive on merit. Some will see a utopian fantasy that ignores human laziness, selfishness, and cruelty.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    Fair enough. This is an opt-in system, not an escape-proof one. The traditional economy continues for those who prefer it. Traditional religion continues. Traditional communities continue. You can leave anytime, no questions asked.

    The catch is that a whole society never does anything one way. So the best path is a decentralized network of networks, interacting with one another, exchanging information and resources and time to pursue their unique purposes. Some high-tech and rapid-learning focused. Others contemplative, low-tech, and slow. Some traditional. Some radically experimental. It would be a system of many models, not one.

    A whole sectionIn Part 8: AI will kill packaged meaning. Let it.

Can the physical world keep up?

Free essentials depend on enough energy and materials, and some things, like beachfront land, can never be made abundant. These answers deal with what stays scarce.

  1. Won’t asteroid mining take forever?

    Probably decades, yes. Humanity has brought home about a quarter pound of asteroid, total.

    That’s why turning outward is the third part of this vision, not the first. Recycling and substitution can carry us for a long time.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    My roadmap in Part 19 puts the outward turn in Stage 5, 2040 and beyond, and for real tonnage I’d bet on later. Still, SpaceX’s Starship has made incredible progress in carrying payloads to space.

    Naming it as a target now makes sure the long-term plan for heavy industry considers it vital, and doesn’t just default to “dig deeper here on Earth, forever.”

    In Part 9: The Earth should be a garden, not a mine

  2. Why not let the market sort it out?

    It is sorting it out. Toward emails.

    Markets are very good at following prices. The trouble is that most stocks aren’t priced at all. Pumping an aquifer costs you the electricity, not the water you’ll never get back.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    In Meadows’ terms, that’s a problem with the rules, not with markets. Bangkok didn’t ban pumping. It licensed and priced it, and the aquifer began to recover.

    Set the rules right, and the market does the rest. That’s not central planning. It’s steering.

    In Part 9: The Earth should be a garden, not a mine

  3. Won’t AI slop make everything worthless?

    It’ll make copies worthless. That’s different.

    Look at Deezer again: half the uploads, 1 to 3% of the streams. Slop is the best advertisement sources have ever had. When anything can be faked, the question that matters becomes “who made this, and can I trust them?”

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    Platforms are already acting on that. Deezer has said it will keep fully AI-generated music out of its algorithmic recommendations and editorial playlists.

    Kelly called this findability: when everything is free, the work of sorting it becomes valuable. That’s a craft too. I’d expect guilds of curators.

    In Part 11: Remix will kill the copy, not the creator

  4. Isn’t luxury just going to get more extreme?

    Probably, at the very top. Hirsch argued that richer societies fight harder over positional goods, not less, and I don’t think abundance repeals that.

    But two things change. First, the floor. When losing a status race no longer costs you your home or your healthcare, the stakes drop from survival to pride.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    Second, the tax base. As I wrote in Part 18: Every Spending Bill Should Show Up on Your Paycheck, “What’s left is a small tax base on whatever stays scarce: land, luxury goods, and positional goods.” If people want to compete over beachfront, the beachfront can help pay for the floor.

    In Part 11: Remix will kill the copy, not the creator

  5. Can provenance survive remixing?

    Partly. Here’s where it breaks.

    The C2PA’s own explainer asks, “Can the provenance metadata be removed?” and answers, “Yes it can.”

    Its fix is to pair the signed record with watermarks and fingerprints, so the record can be found again after it’s stripped. Content ID already matches the media itself, not its labels.

    Read the full answer (4 more paragraphs)

    Model-level remixing is harder. When a model writes a paragraph, there’s usually no single source to point to. That’s exactly why music invented blanket licenses: when you can’t trace every thread, you pay into a pool and distribute it by the best evidence you have.

    Even simple matching is hard.

    When the Mechanical Licensing Collective, a nonprofit created by the Music Modernization Act of 2018, opened in 2021, streaming services handed it more than $424 million in “black box” royalties they’d never been able to match to songwriters.

    So provenance won’t be perfect. Neither are ASCAP’s distributions. It has to be good enough, open to audit, and improving every year.

    In Part 11: Remix will kill the copy, not the creator

  6. Why spend on space when Earth has problems?

    This is the oldest version of the question, and it got one of the best answers.

    In 1970, a nun working in Zambia, Sister Mary Jucunda, wrote to Ernst Stuhlinger, a NASA scientist, asking how he could justify spending billions on space while children were starving. His reply included a copy of the Earthrise photo and a parable.

    Read the full answer (5 more paragraphs)

    A medieval count gave generously to his poor, plague-stricken town, but also kept paying a strange man who spent his days grinding lenses. The townspeople were furious. The lenses became the microscope, which went on to help medicine beat the plague and other contagious diseases.

    Three more points from me.

    First, the sequence matters. The floor comes first in this series. The frontier is stage five, not stage one.

    Second, the money is smaller than people think. According to the Planetary Society, NASA accounted for about 0.35% of US federal spending in 2025.

    Third, space is an Earth problem. Moving heavy mining off-planet is how we conserve the stocks down here. And every person who sees the planet whole comes back more likely to care for it.

    In Part 16: Above self-actualization is the universe

  7. Isn’t a market for essentials what went wrong in Texas?

    Two different things went wrong in Texas. The blackouts came from power plants and gas lines freezing. The giant bills came from handing a wholesale price straight to families.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    The design here takes on the second directly: towns trade, and households sit behind the lifeline block.

    And if a region does try need-based credits, they hold the line Wörgl crossed: issued by need, spent only on the federation’s shared reserve, recirculated every period, and never cashed out.

    In Part 17: Keep money, add a second ledger

  8. But are they building the right things?

    This is my real critique. Not whether they should build, but whether they’re building the right kinds of chips and the right model architectures.

    I’m not alone in asking. Rich Sutton, one of the founders of reinforcement learning, wrote “The Bitter Lesson,” the essay so many AI researchers point to when they argue for scaling.

    Read the full answer (5 more paragraphs)

    He now argues that large language models are the wrong place to start, because they learn to mimic people instead of learning from experience, and he’s working on a new architecture of his own.

    On the Dwarkesh Podcast, he said he’s “content being out of sync with my field for a long period of time, perhaps decades,” and then reframed it: “I really view myself as a classicist rather than as a contrarian.”

    That’s how I feel about these ideas. If the person whose work justified the scaling race thinks there’s something better, it’s safe to assume there is.

    And all of this is software. From a certain point of view, everything is software.

    Or at least, every system runs on a series of rules that can be written down, tested, and rewritten like software. The economy included.

    In Part 22: Five takes the AI industry needs to ingest

  9. What do we pool?

    What about the “startup capital” required to pool your resources?

    Without traditional wages from labor like we know it today, what will guilds and parties who invest in quests and trades together use as our primary resource to pool?

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    How will humans continue to trade with and trust one another if we don’t have “jobs” like we used to?

    A whole sectionIn Part 6: UBI won’t work. Universal basic goods will.

  10. What about scarce wants?

    Not everything can be free. Beachfront land and original art are scarce by nature. This is where money or another similar mechanism may persist for the rest.

    We’ve now covered what the world we want looks like: machine labor on demand, scarcity engineered away, communities that own their machines, parties and guilds that organize the work, and the things themselves instead of a check.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    The next question is the hardest one: how do we actually get there from here? That’s Part 7: We’re Less Than a Decade From the Next Economic System.

    A whole sectionIn Part 6: UBI won’t work. Universal basic goods will.

  11. Why are robots writing emails?

    Follow the money. Stanford’s AI Index counted $581.7 billion in corporate AI investment in 2025. Of the $344.7 billion in private investment, the largest focus area by far, AI infrastructure, models, research and governance, took $143.2 billion.

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    Sorted another way, by what the companies make, generative AI companies drew $170.9 billion. The two counts overlap, but they point the same way. Robotics and energy management trailed far behind.

    Now follow the attention. In the latest earnings season, “AI” came up on 331 of 493 S&P 500 earnings calls, or 67%, the third straight quarter above 65%.

    A whole sectionIn Part 9: The Earth should be a garden, not a mine

Is it legal?

Could this pass, and would today’s Supreme Court let it stand? Part 21 checks each piece against the Constitution, and these are the hardest cases.

  1. Didn’t Jefferson say ideas can’t be property?

    He did, and I agree with him.

    In the same letter, he wrote that society can grant rights to the profits from an idea, but “this may or may not be done, according to the will and convenience of the society.”

    Read the full answer (2 more paragraphs)

    That’s my whole position. Don’t fence the idea. Pay the person.

    A compulsory remix license does exactly that: anyone can remix anything, and everyone in the chain gets paid.

    In Part 11: Remix will kill the copy, not the creator

  2. Isn’t quoting the founders cherry-picking? They also protected slavery and limited who could vote.

    Yes, and that matters. The Constitution as originally conceived excluded most of the people living under it. It got better through amendments, including the 14th, which gives us the equal-protection and right-to-travel cases above.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    I’m not arguing the founders were right about everything. I’m arguing they built a system that can be improved, and that most of the tools for the world we want are already in it.

    In Part 21: The World We Want is mostly constitutional

  3. Doesn’t Prop 40 prove states can do this?

    It proves states have room Congress doesn’t. It doesn’t prove a wealth tax works.

    Wealth can move. That’s exactly why the Georgists liked land: it can’t leave.

    In Part 21: The World We Want is mostly constitutional

  4. Doesn’t the Takings Clause make the gift-back impossible?

    No. It makes the forced gift-back impossible. A gift-back agreed up front is a bargain. A gift-back forced after the fact is a fight. And a buyback at fair value is fully constitutional.

    Read the full answer (1 more paragraph)

    The Fifth Amendment protects what builders build, and Locke would say their labor earned it. Good. That’s an incentive to build.

    In Part 21: The World We Want is mostly constitutional

Futurespective

The best objections end up in the paper

Argue with me in the comments on Futurespective. New essays and films arrive by email, free.